DOCUMENT-BASED QUESTIONS/ ESSAY
This
task is based on the accompanying documents (1-8). Some of these
documents have been edited for the purposes of this task. This task is
designed to test your ability to work with historical documents. As you
analyze the documents, take into account both the source of each
document and the author’s point of view.
Directions:
Read the
documents in Part A and answer the questions after each document (do
not simply
repeat the contents of the documents). Then read the directions for
Part B and write your essay.
Historical Context:
When Brooklyn Dodgers owner Branch Rickey signed Jackie Robinson to a
major league contract in 1945, they agreed to avoid confrontations until
Robinson was an established player. As Jackie Robinson became an
integral part of the Dodgers lineup, he became a visible and outspoken
opponent of prejudice, discrimination, and racism. He educated people
on and off the field about the evils of bigotry and helped lead the way
in the struggle for African-American civil rights in the United States.
Task:
Describe the accomplishments of Jackie Robinson in the struggle for
desegregation and how
his actions challenged racism and discrimination in the United States.
Instructions &
Directions, New York State Education Department, GH-888-98, 1999.
Historical Context, Task, Document Selection, and Organization,
Douglas J. Kaufman, 2001.
Part A: Short Answer
Directions:
Analyze the documents and answer the questions that follow each document
in the
space provided.
Document 1
“The people who go
to baseball games do not, in the main, go to lectures on race
relations, nor do they read pamphlets about good-will. The millions
who read box scores very likely have never heard of George Washington
Carver. But Jackie Robinson . . . will be doing the missionary work
with these people that Carver could never do. He will be saying to
them that his people should have their rights, should have jobs,
decent homes and education, freedom from insult, and equality of
opportunity to achieve.”
-Roy Wilkins,
Michigan Chronicle.
1.According
to Roy Wilkins, why is Jackie Robinson important to the African American
civil rights movement?
Detroit’s Michigan Chronicle. Roy Wilkins, November 3, 1945.
Excerpted from Phylon: The Atlanta University Review of Race and
Culture by Bill L. Weaver. December, 1979.
From
collection of The National
Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum.
Task, Historical Context, Document Selection, Question , Douglas J.
Kaufman, 2001.
Document 2
“Robinson is not
only great because he can hit and field, but great because he
withstood the greatest test last year any baseball player experienced
in the history of the game. He not only had to combat the opposing
pitchers and base-runners but at all times appear to be ‘the perfect
model.’ He was constantly under restraint and at times when he had
the perfect right to speak up and protest against certain conditions,
there was nothing he could do but grit his teeth and keep going.
Living and playing in such a rigid atmosphere was far from easy. When
something happened that he disliked, Robinson had to constantly remind
himself that he was a Negro in organized baseball, unwanted generally
but, nevertheless, there. He had to say to himself: ‘Although I want
to rise up and fight back and challenge my tormentors, I can’t. Even
if I’m right, someone will try to prove that I am wrong. There are
no less than 14 million Negroes involved in this thing. I am their
representative and I can’t afford to let them down. I’ll just have to
stick it out and do the very best I can.’”
- Wendell Smith,
The Pittsburgh Courier, March
5, 1947
“Jackie Robinson . .
. faced pitchers and defensive players who displayed more zest to get
him out than any player in history. . . But Robinson’s been going his
merry-way, hitting around .300 all season, leading the league in runs
scored and stolen bases. He’s taken taunts and bellowing cracks of
the enemy in stride, and somehow managed to hold his head under the
most trying circumstances. . . Robinson definitely has delivered . .
.”
- Wendell Smith, The
Pittsburgh Courier, August 9,
1947
2.
Why did Jackie Robinson resist the temptation to retaliate
against his “tormentors”?
3.
How did Jackie Robinson’s actions contribute to the success of
baseball integration?
Excerpted from The
Pittsburgh Courier. The Sports Beat by Wendell Smith.
March 15, 1947 and August 9, 1947.
From collection of The National
Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum.
Task, Historical Context, Document Selection, Questions, Douglas J.
Kaufman, 2001.
Document 3
4.
What fault does Jackie Robinson find with those who support segregation
in the United States?
5.
According to Jackie Robinson, why must everyone ‘continue to
press for’ African-American civil
rights?
Excerpted from the collection of
The National Baseball Hall of Fame
and Museum.
Task, Historical Context, Document Selection/ Questions, Douglas J.
Kaufman, 2001.
Document 4
Cheers by Georgia Fans ‘Biggest Thrill for Jackie
By
ARCH MURRAY
Atlanta, April. 9 –
There was a big grin on Jackie Robinson’s face as he sat in a corner
of the dugout just before the history-making game here last night.
The crowd was pouring in, spilling over onto the hill back of center
field. But there wasn’t a sign of animosity he had feared so much.
“You know,” he said, “how I’ve been dreading this weekend. Well, I
learned last night in Macon I’d been worrying far too much. The
reception there was the best I’ve gotten anywhere on this trip. . .”
“It all goes to prove,” he added, “that fans are all alike no matter
whet section of the country they come from. It sure does make a
fellow feel good, though. It’s one of the biggest thrills I’ve ever
had.”
A little while later . . . Jackie strode up to the plate for the first
time in the capital of the state where he was born.
First there was a mild roar of enthusiasm from the bleachers where his
people were clustered. Then came the boos of the bigoted whites –
boos that died in their throats as the good sportsmanship of the
average American took command. Then the white folks began to clap and
a lot of them could be heard yelling, “C’mon Jackie!”
Once again he responded just as he had the night before. . . He added
another hit later, giving him five in eight trips on his native
Georgia soil.
His hitting these last two nights has been a tremendous tribute to
his competitive temperament. For it wasn’t easy coming in a part of
the country where the Ku Klux Klan was muttering menacing but empty
grumbles. . .
But Jackie was still nervous when he stepped up to the plate in Macon.
. . “Finally, though, I loosened up and smacked one to left field. I
heard the clapping and the cheers and I knew everything was going to
be all right.”
6.
Why was Jackie Robinson worried about playing in Macon, Georgia?
7. How was Jackie Robinson able to get the crowd in Georgia to support
him?
Excerpted from article, Cheers by Georgia Fans ‘Biggest Thrill’ for
Jackie. April 10, 1949.
From collection of The National
Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum.
Task, Historical Context, Document Selection, Questions, Douglas J.
Kaufman, 2001.
Document 5
“Pee Wee (Reese)
is a (white) Southerner, born in Ekron, Kentucky, and he took a lot of
abuse because of his consideration of me. . . Because he was a
Kentuckian, the bench jockeys all over the circuit rode him, a great
shortstop, asking him how it felt playing next to a Negro. In our
first game at Boston, the Braves tried to give us a real bad time.
But Pee Wee shut them up. He walked over to me, put his arm around me
and talked to me in a warm and friendly way, smiling and laughing.
His sincerity startled the Braves, and there was no more trouble after
that from them. Later, he did the same for me in other ball parks. .
.
. . .For every
player who tried to upset me that (first) season, there were two or
three others, like Joe Medwick and Hank Greenberg, who gave me a
helping hand. Greenberg was playing for the Pirates then, and he used
to talk to me encouragingly when I was on first base. He told me that
he, too, had run into discrimination as a rookie because he was
Jewish, but he assured me that everything would turn out all right for
me. . .
Today, I can’t
help thinking how much these things have changed in the past eight
years. . . I’ve seen this especially in the South. . . We’ve played in
many places in the South when the Ku Klux Klan threatened to run me
off the field, but I was besieged by white teenagers for autographs.
I’m sure that many of these youngsters were the sons and daughters of
klan members. . .
While I was the
White House, one of the secretaries told me a Southerner had been
there earlier to defend the segregation laws that were being
considered by the Supreme Court. He had brought his grandson with
him. As he was carrying on about the dangers of giving Negroes equal
rights, the little boy was tugging at his sleeve. ‘Let’s go back to
the hotel Granddaddy,’ the boy was saying. ‘I heard Jackie Robinson
is staying there and I want to see if I can get his autograph.’”
- Jackie Robinson, 1955
8.
Why did some baseball players befriend Jackie Robinson when he
broke the color barrier in major
league baseball?
9.
How did Jackie Robinson’s abilities as a ballplayer help to change
racist attitudes?
Excerpted from the article A Kentucky
Colonel Kept Me in Baseball.
From collection of The National
Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum.
Task, Historical Context, Document Selection, Questions, Douglas J.
Kaufman, 2001.
Document 6
10. What was the source of most of Jackie Robinson’s
income in 1947 ?
11. What does Jackie Robinson’s income in 1947 indicate about his
popularity?
The Pittsburgh Courier. October 4,
1947.
From collection of The
National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum.
Task, Historical Context, Document Selection, Questions, Douglas J.
Kaufman, 2001.
Document 7
“I play hard all the time. But I’m
going to slacken my aggressiveness in some respects (in 1952). Not
because of the Negro question, though. I’ve got an executive job at
NBC now, and I must watch the way I conduct myself. When I have a
legitimate beef, I’ll make it, and get out there quickly. If it
doesn’t concern me, I won’t put my two cents in. (As a direct result
of Robinson’s baseball achievements, National Broadcasting Company
named Jackie ‘Director of Community Activities,’ last winter, making
him NBC’s first Negro executive.) . . .
(The) biggest improvement has been in the
social relationship between white and Negro players. There’s been a
big change in the attitude of the men. . . I start a game and the
other men join me. I’m asked – and I sit in. That’s a far cry from
1947. Off the field, social relationships are not unusual. Things
are easy, accepted. I go to dinners with other Dodgers, play golf,
get invited out with my wife. . .
I’ve received plenty of crank letters since
I’ve been with Brooklyn. . . Now I show them to all the men. . . I got
a letter in 1951 threatening my life. The next day the players got
together in the dugout and said they’d all put on black face and wear
my number ‘42’ so the would-be killer wouldn’t know who to shoot at.
That made me feel real good. . .
The Phils were rough on me when Ben Chapman
managed them. I remember he once was quoted as saying, he ‘beat up
niggers in his spare time’. . . The Dodgers told me, too, that they
were disgusted. I always felt that day marked the welding of the
club.
White Southerners, by their association with
Negro players, have learned to respect them . . . Some of them seem to
realize that what they may have believed about Negroes all their lives
is just false. The fans want good playing. They’ll cheer anyone –
regardless of color – for a good play.”
-
Jackie Robinson, Focus. July, 1952
12.
In addition to breaking the color barrier in twentieth century
major league baseball, what other first did Jackie Robinson accomplish?
13.
According to Jackie Robinson, how did his involvement (and that
of other African Americans)
help to change racist attitudes?
Excerpted from the Focus
article, Jackie Robinson- Five Years In White Man’s Baseball,
July 1952..
From
collection of The National
Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum.
Task, Historical Context, Document Selection, Questions,
Douglas J. Kaufman, 2001.
Document 8
May 13, 1958
The President (Dwight
D. Eisenhower)
The White House
Washington, D.C.
My Dear Mr. President:
I was sitting in the
audience at the Summit Meeting of Negro Leaders yesterday when you
said we must have patience. On hearing you say this, I felt like
standing up and saying, “Oh no! Not again.”
I respectfully remind
you sir, that we have been the most patient of all people. When you
say we must have self-respect, I wondered how we could have
self-respect and remain patient considering the treatment accorded us
through the years.
17 million Negroes
cannot do as you suggest and wait for the hearts of men to change. We
want to enjoy now the rights that we feel we are entitled to as
Americans. This we cannot do unless we pursue aggressively goals
which all other Americans achieved over 150 years ago.
As the chief executive
of our nation, I respectfully suggest that you unwittingly crush the
spirit of freedom in Negroes by constantly urging forbearance and give
hope to those pro-segregation leaders like Governor Faubus who would
take from us those freedoms we now enjoy. Your own experience with
Governor Faubus is proof enough that forbearance and not eventual
integration is the goal the pro-segregation leaders seek.
In my view, an
unequivocal statement backed up by action such as you demonstrated you
could take last fall in dealing with Governor Faubus (in Little Rock,
Arkansas) if it became necessary, would let it be known that America
is determined to provide - - in the near future - - for Negroes - -
the freedoms we are entitled to under the constitution.
Respectfully yours,
Jackie Robinson
14. Why does Jackie Robinson claim that African
Americans are the ‘most patient of all people’?
15. According to Jackie Robinson’s letter, what
would be necessary to achieve racial equality?
Excerpted from the National Archives and Records Administration, Dwight
D. Eisenhower Library.
Taken from
http://www.nara.gov/educational/teaching/robinson/ikelet.html
Task, Historical Context, Document Selection, Questions, Douglas J.
Kaufman, 2001.
Part B
Essay
Directions:
·
Write
a well-organized essay that includes an introduction, several
paragraphs, and a conclusion.
·
Use
evidence from the documents to support your response.
·
Do
not simply repeat the contents of the documents.
·
Include specific related outside information.
Historical Context:
When
Brooklyn Dodgers owner Branch Rickey signed Jackie Robinson to a major
league contract in 1945, they agreed to avoid confrontations until
Robinson was an established player. As Jackie Robinson became an
integral part of the Dodgers lineup, he became a visible and outspoken
opponent of prejudice, discrimination, and racism. He educated people
on and off the field about the evils of bigotry and helped lead the way
in the struggle for African-American civil rights in the United States.
Task:
Using information from the documents provided and your knowledge of
United States
history, write an essay describing how Jackie Robinson’s actions
contributed to the struggle for African American civil rights in the
mid-twentieth century.
Be sure to include specific historical details. You must also include
additional information from your knowledge of United States history.
Instructions &
Directions, New York State Education Department, GH-888-98, 1999.
Historical Context, Task, Document Selection, and Organization, Douglas
J. Kaufman, 2001.
Document Sample
What
does the comic book and its advertising suggest about how people reacted
to Jackie Robinson?
Task, Historical Context,
Document Selection, Question, Douglas J. Kaufman, 2001.
From collection of
The National Baseball Hall of Fame
and Museum.
|